Let me just say, first of all, that I am a big fan of Elise
Juska, and that I admire her talent immensely. Getting Over Jack Wagner is one of the funniest novels written by a
woman I've ever read, and her short story “The Way I Saw the World Then” is one
I have read aloud in my writing classes many times as an example of beautifully
written, heart-wrenching literary
fiction. Therefore, when I discovered her new novel, The Blessings, I was so excited I found myself frantically tapping
the good old “Buy with one click” button before I’d even read the sample (in
truth, before I’d even read the summary!)—something I have never, not once,
done before with any other author’s work. So as you can imagine, it was tough
for me to give this book a mere two-star rating.
The Blessings,
which is the story of a large Catholic family experiencing one problem right
after the other, in my humble opinion, reads more like a series of writing
exercises than a novel. For example, Chapter One is told from the point of view
of college-bound daughter Abby. We spend a few pages in her head, getting to
know her and her opinion of her family members, but then the chapter ends and
we move on to another character’s head, and the next time we see Abby again, we
are viewing her through another character’s eyes; she is several years older,
and we have no access whatsoever to her inner self. And so the book goes,
chapter to chapter, character to character, crisis to crisis. As a reader who
likes to become immersed in the hearts and minds of characters, this structure
alone is something I found very unrewarding. We would visit a character for a
few pages, hear his or her tale of woe, and then move on.
The other thing that really bothers me about this book is
that the characters are all so completely self-absorbed and miserable. Don’t
get me wrong; I love drama and am all for torturing fictional characters with
all manner of illness and bad luck. But there is nothing fun about these
characters or their misery. The book is depressing, full of maudlin, discontent
characters, who just do not seem to love one another in any genuine way. I know
one reviewer called this a “bighearted novel,” but where is that heart exactly?
In the couple that can’t cope with their daughter’s bulimia and therefore
divorce; or in the sister-in-law who, after years of trying to get pregnant and
the birth of one child, hints to her husband that she wants to have an abortion
after accidentally becoming pregnant with a second; in the deadbeat son who
attacks an innocent old man in the Wendy’s parking lot so that he and his
friends can rip off his car stereo; in the brother who travels to Spain with
his girlfriend only to mope and sit silently through most of the trip for
reasons I still have yet to fathom; in the doctor husband with two beautiful
children and two homes to boot (one of them beachfront!) who considers having
an affair with a woman he works with just because she can bake cupcakes and his
wife is a lousy cook . . . ? I’m sorry, but I just don’t get it. What this
family needs is a priest or therapist to come along and tell them all that
happiness is often a choice, to remind them that true love is often a matter of
will, and that life is a gift. Ugh. I
could go on and on, but I’ll spare you the rest.
The Good Stuff:
Elise Juska can write—no doubt about it. Her descriptions
are amazing and the dialogue is painfully real.
The Not So Good
Stuff:
See my rantings above.
Overall Score: Even though I am obviously not a fan of The Blessings, I cannot bring myself to assign a score to a writer
whose talent I admire as much as Juska’s.
Bottom Line: I
did not like this novel and would not recommend it to a friend.
